Language / Dil
All Posts Domain Names Business Email SSL Certificates Hosting Trademark Registration Metutech.Design AI-Powered Website Builder ↗ More Back to metunic.com.tr
Digital Marketing

The Dark Side of Big Data

Drawing on Cathy O'Neil's book Weapons of Math Destruction, we look at how algorithms built on big data analysis reproduce society's biases. We discuss how flawed goals and biased data create a self-reinforcing feedback loop.

3 min read

Contents
  1. Big Data and Prejudice
  2. Weapons of Math Destruction
  3. A Self-Feeding Monster
  4. The Observer Changes the Observed

“There is no dark side of the moon; really, the whole thing is dark.”

When big data began to spread in the technology world, the first thing that bothered the big companies in this field was that the phenomenon was getting too much attention. Their fear was that the concept would soon be hollowed out. Over the past ten years, the hollowing out of the concept has gone so far that all the oceans of the world could not fill it up or make it overflow! Thanks to social media! Big data (and its analysis) has been dragged down!

Big Data and Prejudice

If the intent is bad, what can the tool do? When we look at what kinds of purposes big data is used for today, the resulting list is unfortunately tainted. Even in the best case, even assuming there is no ill intent at all, artificial intelligence algorithms based on big data analysis bring to light the prejudices that have been ingrained in humanity for decades, for centuries!

Weapons of Math Destruction

The interesting book on this subject by Cathy O’Neil, who gives her views as the blue-haired expert in the Netflix documentary “Coded Bias”, has also been translated into Turkish. The title of the book is wonderful: Weapons of Math Destruction. We used to have Weapons of Mass Destruction; now we have Weapons of Math Destruction. What we call big data analysis is nothing but mathematics. So what turns mathematics into a weapon of destruction? O’Neil makes a series of observations, starting with the wrong choice of goals, named or unnamed, when algorithms are developed.

For example, when the algorithm of those who say “our algorithm does not discriminate by race” is examined, it can be seen that racism is injected into the process indirectly. How? For example, by building on the motto “geography is destiny”! If you pick the low-income areas of a city and, say, send more police patrols there, the profile of the people you detain will inevitably make you racist. Because who lives in those areas is a given.

A Self-Feeding Monster

In her book, decorated with examples from America, O’Neil describes this as a self-feeding monster. To continue the example above, say police patrol the areas where more African Americans or Hispanics live and resort to harsh measures even for a minor violation. In this case, these individuals, who already live in bad conditions, are more likely to find themselves in prison for trivial reasons. Prisons, instead of working as rehabilitation centers, act almost like units designed to make a person even worse. Thus, a person who got into trouble with the police for a trivial reason two years ago can become a murderer two years later!

The Observer Changes the Observed

The finding in quantum mechanics that the observer changes the observed is confirmed in the macro world by algorithms working with big data. An algorithm that sets out for a cleaner world makes the world dirtier. One that sets out for a better world makes it worse, and one that sets out for a fairer world contributes to the rise of a more unjust one.

This unfortunate feedback mechanism is fed by two sources: the unnamed prejudices (prejudiced decisions) ingrained in the body of experience so far, and the wrong goals loaded into the algorithms developed to process it! In the introduction of her book, O’Neil invites the reader to the dark side of big data. Pink Floyd’s The Dark Side of the Moon, the album that has stayed longest on the world’s music charts, ends with Nick Mason’s observation: “There is no dark side of the moon; really, the whole thing is dark!”

Tanol Türkoğlu – Herkese Bilim Teknoloji Magazine; “Digital Culture” column (Issue 276, 08.07.2021)

Was this article helpful?

Still stuck? Our support team is here to help. Tell us your question and our experts will help you.

Help & Support
Digital Marketing

You may also like

Digital Marketing

The Last Exit Before Mars

In this column, Tanol Türkoğlu asks whether blockchain could transform capitalism by removing trusted third parties such as central banks. The piece argues that data has become the energy source of a new digital economy.